Copper Compounds as Algaecides

 

Copper sulfate and other derivatives of copper have been used to control undesirable algae in lakes and ponds.  Application consists of spreading copper sulfate crystals or powder along problematic areas, or spraying a slurry across the water surface. In most instances, copper sulfate is very effective in killing the floating mats of algae; unfortunately, such control of algae is of very short duration. On the contrary, the negative impacts of the copper sulfate are long term.

Following application of the copper salt, reactive copper concentrations become elevated and remain so for about two hours.  The active copper ions are attracted to carbonate ions and become strongly bound.  This new compound of copper carbonate drops out of the water column and binds up the copper.  The result is that the copper is only effective at killing algae for only two hours.  Button et al. (1977) performed copper experiments in Columbus, Ohio ponds, demonstrating that within two hours, the copper concentrations returned to pretreatment levels.  After this period, only the algae exposed to the copper for the 2 hour time period may die.  However, new algae already begin to grow following the precipitation of the copper.  To add to this, the alga that has been killed is releasing nutrients, spurring new growth.

Besides promoting algae growth as a result of nutrient recycling, copper sulfate kills tiny beneficial animals that filter algae from the water column. Doses of copper sulfate required to kill algae are 10 to 100 times that required to kill these beneficial zooplankton (Cooke and Kennedy 2001).  The result is increased planktonic algae growth with every copper sulfate application.  Cooke and Kennedy affirm this reporting that “very low levels of copper are toxic to algae-grazing zooplankton, leading to a ‘rebound’ of algal biomass as copper is removed from the water column by precipitation within hours of application.”

For drinking water ponds, there is also concern of the copper-induced release of toxins from blue-green algae. Specific types of algae produce toxins harmful to humans and pets. These toxins can cause gastrointestinal distress, liver failure, and even death (Hitzfeld et al. 2000). Bluegreen algae blooms are more prevalent in ponds without algae-grazing zooplankton, a situation that can result from copper treatments (Cooke and Kennedy 2001).  Copper sulfate has also caused species of bluegreen algae cells to lyse, causing the release of hepatotoxins into the water column (Lam et al. 1995).  Because typical water treatment methods have limited ability to remove these toxins, preventing the growth of these algae is key.

Finally, copper sulfate negatively affects the benthic community in lakes and ponds. The rapid precipitation of the copper ions causes the accumulation of the copper in the bottom sediments.  At this point, the copper reduces the diversity of benthic organisms that maintain the aquatic ecosystem.  Most importantly, benthic microbe (bacteria) growth is inhibited by elevated copper concentrations.  Without microbes, dead organic material accumulates on the pond bottom, causing a rapid filling of the pond.  Without the use of copper, microbes will thrive on the dead organic material and will slow the filling process of the pond.

Copper sulfate has historically provided a quick fix for algae problems in lakes and ponds.  Unfortunately, the long-term side-effects outweigh the short-lived benefits. While attempting to make ponds more aesthetically pleasing, the balance of the ecosystem is skewed, pond filling accelerates, and the possibility of algae toxicity increases.  The best solution for excessive algae is to eliminate copper usage and to adopt a Holistic Approach. This approach includes aeration, microbial augmentation, and physical removal.

 

 

 

References

Button, K.S., H.P. Hostetter, and D.M. Mair.  1977.  Copper dispersal in a water supply reservoir.  Wat. Res.  11:539-544.

Cooke, G.D. and R.H. Kennedy.  2001.  Managing drinking water supplies.  Lake and Reserv. Manage.  17(3):157-174

Hitzfeld, B.C., S.J.Hoger, and D.R. Dietrich.  2000.  Cyanobacterial toxins:  Removal during drinking water treatment, and human risk assessment.  Environ. Health  Perspectives 108: 113-122.

Lam, A. K-Y., E.E. Prepas, D. Spink, and S.E. Hrudey.  1995.  Chemical control of hepatotoxic phytoplankton blooms: Implications for human health.  Water Res. 29:1845-1854.

 

 

All Tilapia are NOT Equal

IBN sells ONLY Pure Blue Tilapia NOT hybrid Tilapia. When you buy Blue Tilapia from IBN you get:

  • 6" plus fish that are Brood Stock - ready to reproduce
  • Blue Tilapia live longer 
  • Begin eating plant material right away

Why Stocking "Tilapia" is not the same

  • Smaller Sized Fish are not ready to reproduce
  • Stocked Later in Season
  • Die Earlier in Season

 

By stocking smaller Tilapia you will NOT have the same amount of overall consumption! Don't fall into the trap of buying smaller fish. 

 

Key to Natural Pond Management

Nutrients are key in natural pond management. Our management techniques identify nutrient problems, develop means of reducing nutrient input, and provide long term control of residual nutrients. In doing so, we are taking the excessive nutrients responsible for nuisance plant growth and converting them into more manageable plant and animal growth.  Using an array of tools such as Beneficial Microbes and Bottom Aeration, Inspired By Nature, Inc. provides safe, low maintenance, and affordable solutions for your pond or lake.

To inquire or order any of our products or services please contact us at 419-669-4084

Tilapia

In 2010, we introduced Blue Tilapia as a tool to help manage ponds naturally. Since that time we have seen incredible results! Tilapia are NOT a magic bullet but when used at proper stocking rates they can be a very effective. Tilapia alone are not going to solve all of your pond troubles! Read more about Tilapia here

Schooner Farms

Sustainable, Non-Conventional Farming, inspired by nature! In 2009 we added another segment ot our business - Schooner Farms. Visit us at www.schoonerberries.com

  • Raw Honey
  • CSA (Community Supported Agriculture)
  • Educational Classes
  • Pasture Raised & Certified Organically Fed Poultry & Fresh Eggs
  • Volunteer & Intern Opportunities
  • Shiitake Mushrooms
  • and more